Examancer

Firefox performance in linux is always a bit lacking, so I thought I’d try some of the many alternative web browsers for Ubuntu (Gnome). All of these were tested on an Acer AspireOne running Ubuntu 8.10 and all were installed through the Ubuntu package repositories.

Midori

A small and simple WebKit browser. I have been looking for a good WebKit browser to use in linux… unfortunately this isn’t it. The performance is pretty decent when loading and using the page itself, but the actual program UI is clunky, slow, and buggy. This one needs some serious GTK+ work before it can expect to be a real choice for Ubuntu users. It hasn’t crashed on me or anything, but the fact that the toolbar can get resized if you switch tabs or use the back/forward buttons should not happen, but it does and it happens slowly.

Epiphany

Uses the Gecko layout engine, like Firefox, and seems to do it a little slower than Firefox. Some of the tab behaviors are odd and difficult to configure. When I click on a link that should open in a new window I generally don’t want it to appear in a new window, I want it in a new tab. Back and forward history seem to be shared among tabs in the same window? I guess I could see how that would be useful, but it is very odd behavior. Double clicking in the empty area of the tab bar doesn’t spawn a new tab? Also odd. All-in-all this isn’t a bad browser, it just doesn’t seem to do anything better than Firefox, which I was really hoping for.

Galeon

This is another browser using the Gecko layout engine. This browser actually feels pretty fast. I have enjoyed using it. However, it is not without issues. On a netbook it is very frustrating that I cannot seem to configure the browser’s UI to take up a minimal amount of screen space. The stock back and forward buttons are huge, and the height of the toolbar they are on is way to large. Even in full screen, the UI takes up too much vertical screen real estate.

These are the only alternative browsers I have tried so far. None of these browsers offer a good alternative to Firefox on a screen-space-constrained netbook. Not a single browser here had a windowed or full screen mode that offered as much screen real-estate dedicated to displaying the web page as Firefox (when properly configured). Even after exploring the various configuration options there appears to be no way to make ANY of these browsers use less or even similar amounts of screen-space for their UI compared to Firefox (not counting the options to remove the toolbar entirely, which is not realistic) . On a screen this small page real-estate becomes very important. There should at least be OPTIONS to make the UI as minimal as possible, but the options provided are simply inadequate. This compounds the fact that Midori and Epiphany both feel slower than Firefox. Galeon, which generally feels as fast or faster than Firefox, is crippled for me by the fact that the minimum usable UI configuration is the largest of the group. Also, not a single one of these browsers offers the ability have a FULL full-screen browser, like Firefox, where the UI auto-hides and the web page is given nearly 100% of the screen. I hope with the growing number of netbook users and the growing number of them running linux this will have to be a form factor each brower’s community will develop for and offer more customizable/minimizable user interfaces.

Tags: acer, AspireOne, epiphany, firefox, galeon, gnome, linux, midori, ubuntu

This entry was posted on Sunday, February 22nd, 2009 at 12:17 pm and is filed under Technology. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.